Investing/Open-Ended vs. Close-Ended Mutual Funds in Nepal: Which Should You Buy?
Current Chapter 03/07·0% Completed
Investing
Module 02: Systematic Investment Plans (SIP) in Nepal
Open-Ended vs. Close-Ended Mutual Funds in Nepal: Which Should You Buy?
Understand how open-ended funds buy back your units daily at NAV while close-ended funds trade on NEPSE at market-driven discounts or premiums.
01.What is this?
In Nepal's capital market, mutual funds operate under two distinct structural models regulated by SEBON. A close-ended fund raises capital once through an IPO, lists on NEPSE with a fixed maturity period (e.g., 7 or 10 years), and trades between buyers and sellers. An open-ended fund operates continuously without a maturity date: you buy units directly from the fund manager at today's published NAV, and when you want your money back, the fund manager repurchases your units.
02.Why does it matter?
Many retail investors in Nepal purchase close-ended mutual funds on NEPSE without realizing they cannot be redeemed on demand with the fund house - they must find a buyer on TMS. Conversely, investors wanting a monthly SIP often do not know that only open-ended schemes (like NIBL Sahabhagita Fund or Siddhartha Systematic Investment Scheme) support recurring automated debits.
03.How does it work?
Step 01
Choose Your Investment Method
If you want disciplined monthly investing from your bank account, choose an open-ended scheme. If you have lump-sum cash and want to buy assets at a discount to intrinsic value on NEPSE, analyze close-ended funds.
Step 02
Evaluate NAV vs. Market Price
For close-ended funds, compare the NEPSE market price against the weekly/monthly NAV published by the AMC. If the NAV is NPR 12.50 but the stock trades at NPR 10.00, it trades at a 20% discount.
Step 03
Execution Mechanics
Open-ended units are purchased via the fund manager's online portal or distributor bank counters using connectIPS. Close-ended units are purchased through your broker TMS using ticker symbols like NBF2, SEF, or CMF2.
Step 04
Redemption or Maturity Payout
Open-ended units are redeemed anytime at prevailing NAV minus exit load directly into your bank account within 2-4 business days. Close-ended funds distribute total accumulated net assets to unitholders upon completing their 7-10 year term.
04.Visual Learning & Comparison
Structural Comparison: Open-Ended vs Close-Ended Funds in Nepal
Feature
Open-Ended Scheme
Close-Ended Scheme
Trading Platform
Direct with Fund Manager (AMC portal/counters)
NEPSE Secondary Market (via Broker TMS)
Maturity Period
Perpetual (No expiry date)
Fixed Term (Typically 7 to 10 years)
Pricing Mechanism
Always bought/sold at exact NAV
Market demand/supply (frequently at discount to NAV)
Liquidity Provider
Fund Manager guarantees redemption buyback
Other market participants on NEPSE
SIP Compatibility
Fully supported (Monthly auto-debit)
Not possible for automated recurring SIPs
Exit Costs
Exit load (0% to 1.5% depending on holding period)
Close-ended schemes historically dominate NEPSE, but open-ended funds have surged in popularity since SEBON approved schemes like NIBL Sahabhagita Fund, Siddhartha Systematic Investment Scheme, and NIC Asia Dynamic Debt Fund. An enduring anomaly in Nepal is that close-ended funds frequently trade at a 15%-25% discount to NAV because retail traders prioritize speculative hydro stocks over stable mutual fund units. Value investors often accumulate these discounted units to collect high cash dividend yields.
Regulatory Note: Statutory tax brackets, regulatory fees, and monetary caps reflect current official practice and are subject to periodic amendment in annual Nepal Finance Acts and NRB circulars. Always verify the latest gazetted directives before financial execution.
06.Practical Real-World Example in Nepal
Nisha, 31, staff nurse in Biratnagar
NPR 48,000 / month salary
NPR 1,80,000 invested automatically over 36 months without broker involvement
The Situation:
Nisha wanted to invest NPR 5,000 every month without watching stock charts every day. A colleague suggested buying close-ended units on TMS, but she found placing monthly broker buy orders stressful and irregular.
The RisePaisa Strategy:
She switched to an open-ended mutual fund (NIBL Sahabhagita Fund) and registered an e-mandate SIP through connectIPS. Every month on the 5th, NPR 5,000 is automatically debited and converted into units at that day's NAV. Over 3 years, she accumulated 2,140 units worth NPR 32,500 in gains without placing a single manual trade.
Dipesh's Mutual Fund Route: Monthly SIP in Open-Ended Scheme vs Lump Sum in Secondary Close-Ended Units
Goal & Dilemma: Investing NPR 10,000 monthly for a 7-year horizon.
Option A: Manual lump-sum trading of close-ended mutual fund units on NEPSE TMSHigh Friction for Beginners
Requires constant TMS monitoring, broker commission overhead, and faces wide bid-ask spreads during low volume periods.
Option B: Automated monthly SIP in an open-ended mutual fund (e.g. NIBL Sahabhagita or Siddhartha Systematic)Optimal & Recommended
Transacts seamlessly at real NAV via ConnectIPS, dollar-cost averages across market cycles, and reinvests all dividends automatically.
Decision Takeaway: For effortless monthly compounding, open-ended funds with automated SIPs are unmatched. Use close-ended funds only when trading at massive discounts on NEPSE.
07.Advantages & Limitations
Key Advantages
Open-ended funds allow continuous SIP investments directly from the fund manager at verified Net Asset Value (NAV).
Close-ended funds trade like ordinary shares on NEPSE, often available at deep discounts to their intrinsic NAV.
Provides instant professional diversification across 30+ equities with zero single-stock research burden.
Regulated strictly under SEBON Mutual Fund Regulations 2067 with institutional custodians.
Limitations & Risks
Close-ended funds have a fixed maturity period (typically 5, 7, or 10 years) before forced liquidation.
Close-ended funds suffer from illiquidity on NEPSE during bear markets, making selling at NAV impossible.
Annual fund management and custodial fees (1.5-2.0%) reduce gross compounding returns.
Fund returns are fundamentally tethered to overall NEPSE index market performance.
08.Who Should Use This (And Who Should Avoid It)
Ideal For:
Beginners wanting stock market exposure without the time to research individual balance sheets.
Salaried professionals setting up automated monthly SIPs via ConnectIPS in open-ended schemes.
Value investors seeking discounted close-ended units on NEPSE trading 15-25% below intrinsic NAV.
Caution / Avoid If:
Active traders seeking quick daily price swings and intra-day volatility.
Investors wanting direct control over individual company voting rights and share certificates.
09.Financial Formula & Step-by-Step Calculation
Mathematical Model
Mutual Fund Discount / Exit Load Formula
Discount% = NAV - Market PriceNAV × 100 | Redemption Value = U × NAV × (1 - Exit Load)
Variable Breakdown:
NAV
Net Asset Value
Per-unit value of underlying assets calculated and published by AMC.
Market Price
NEPSE Trading Price
The price at which close-ended units trade on the secondary stock exchange.
Exit Load
Redemption Fee
Fee charged by open-ended funds for selling within minimum holding windows (typically 0.5% - 1.5%).
U
Number of Units
The total mutual fund units being redeemed.
Worked Nepal Scenario:
Close-ended scheme NAV = NPR 12.00, NEPSE price = NPR 9.60. Discount = ((12.00 - 9.60) / 12.00) * 100 = 20% discount. For open-ended: redeeming 1,000 units at NAV NPR 14 with 1% exit load = 1,000 * 14 * 0.99 = NPR 13,860 net payout.
10.Common Mistakes to Avoid in Nepal
Common Pitfall
Trying to set up a monthly SIP on NEPSE with close-ended units.
RisePaisa Best Practice
SIP requires open-ended schemes where new units are created dynamically at current NAV.
Why: Close-ended funds have a fixed unit supply; you cannot create new units each month, and brokers do not support automated micro-SIP debits.
Common Pitfall
Panicking when close-ended fund price falls below NAV.
RisePaisa Best Practice
Trading at a discount is normal in NEPSE. As the fund nears its 7-10 year maturity, market price naturally converges toward NAV.
Why: At maturity, the fund liquidates all shares and pays unitholders the full underlying NAV, closing the discount gap.
Common Pitfall
Ignoring exit load when withdrawing open-ended funds within 6 months.
RisePaisa Best Practice
Hold open-ended equity units for at least 12-24 months so the exit load drops to 0%.
Why: Exit loads penalize short-term traders to protect long-term unitholders from sudden liquidity drains.
Yes. You submit a redemption request through the fund manager's online portal. Payment is deposited directly into your linked bank account via connectIPS within 2 to 4 working days.
Because retail NEPSE investors favor high-beta speculative stocks over diversified mutual funds. This low secondary market demand keeps fund share prices below their underlying portfolio value.
Open-ended funds are significantly better for beginners because they enable automated monthly SIPs, eliminate the stress of stock market timing, and guarantee redemptions at fair intrinsic NAV.
The fund manager liquidates all underlying holdings into cash and pays out the final net asset value per unit directly to unit-holders' bank accounts, or converts it into an open-ended scheme if approved by unit-holders.
Cash dividends distributed by mutual funds to individual investors are subject to a final withholding tax (TDS) of 5% at source under the Income Tax Act.